New York Daily Photo Analytics

Wednesday, April 02, 2008

Lone Voice

I was surprised to learn that this structure is actually quite new - construction dates back only 30 years to 1978. This is St. George's Ukrainian Catholic Church at 20 East 7th Street at the corner of Taras Shevchenko Place. The Byzantine church with its large dome, designed by Apollinaire Osadca, is a landmark in this area of the East Village, which has a large Ukrainian community. The church stands out particularly in contrast to the surrounding lowrise, tenement buildings. It replaces an earlier church - read the history here.
A neighboring project cross the street has been quite controversial - the short two-story Hewitt Memorial Building, belonging to Cooper Union, has been torn down and is being replaced with a 9 story building (equal in height to a 16 story residential building), to be completed in 2009, in time for their 150th anniverary. The new building is the NYC debut of architect, Thom Mayne, a Pritzker Prize laureate and a principal of the Los Angeles firm Morphosis. There has been some community acceptance owing to the new building's transparent features, permitting light and views - read about it here. Cooper Union (and others) have recently been involved in a number of building projects in the area- this is not the first recent neighborhood controversy.
People resist change and opposition to new construction is the norm unless the thing being torn down is absolutely egregious and the replacement very much in keeping with surrounding architecture. Otherwise, in NYC, get ready for a community battle. I'm not saying that all new construction is good - to the contrary, I am a devout preservationist and love historic architecture. However, new construction is a reality anywhere. It's the design process and site considerations that make it such a thorny, contentious matter.
I recall a recent community meeting where there was heated debate over a large scale project. An older, calm and reasonable gentleman stood up and stated that he was a 50 year resident of the neighborhood and of course had seen this type of opposition repeatedly with a consistent outcome - people eventually warm up to the new construction and make it their own. He thought the newly proposed project had been well designed and should be embraced. But he was a lone voice ...

Street Note: Taras Shevchenko Place is only one block long, between 6th and 7th Streets. Originally it was named Hall Street, then Hall Place. Ukrainian residents got the street renamed in 1978. Taras Shevchenko (1814-1861) was a Ukrainian poet, artist and nationalist.


Lucy said...

the photo makes it look like a slice of Europe somewhere. Nice to have some of the traditional cultures still in the old neighborhoods with the architecture, but putting some new things in can definitely spruce things up...

Chuck Pefley said...

Ming, surprising, yet considering the diverse nature of the city, not so surprising. This is a lovely building. Seeing it in isolation I'd be hard put to guess the city.

Brian said...

Chuck -
Thanks and BTW - I am not Ming - he does another NYC photo blog.

Karen said...

Amazing photos. I'm desperately missing Manhattan. I went to SVA for 3 years (I'm a Jersey girl) and now I'm doing art therapy research in South Africa. It's wonderful to get a daily pic of NYC while I'm so far. I was wondering, what camera do you use?



~mona~ said...


I want to thank you for your Daily Photo Blog. I live in Los Angeles and my son lives in Brooklyn, so it's a great link to his world for me.

Your blog is so well written and researched. I love the richness of the connections you create.

Thanks! Mona